Here is the new question :
Sam and Jack had 80 erasers in total. After Sam giving 1/3 of his erasers and Jack, Sam and Jack had an equal number of erasers. How many erasers did Sam have in the beginning?
Using modern Method: Let the numbers of the erasers in the beginning=X,
then we have X-(X/3)=40,
we can simplify it 2X/3=40,
So, we get X=60
Using the Egyptian 'false position' method,
we have to choose the number divisible by 3, let X=9,
then, we have 9-(9/3)=6, but 40 is not the multiple of 6, so try again,
let X=12, then 12-(12/3)=8, but we need 40, which is 5 times as big as 12.
we have X=12*5=60, we check 60 with the equation, 60-(60/3)=40
Therefore, in the beginning, Sam had 60 erasers.
Very nice, Megan! It's good that you showed why 9 wouldn't work. How did you choose x=12? (And what about going with the smallest number, x=3? Is that a method that would work every time? Can you convince me of that?)
ReplyDelete